Jeff Astle
W.B.A.
Alan Ball
Everton
Alan Ball
Arsenal
Gordon Banks
Stoke City
Colin Bell
Manchester City
George Best
Manchester United
Alan Birchenall
Crystal Palace (70/71)
Peter Bonetti
Chelsea
Tony Book
Manchester City
Billy Bremner
Leeds United
Tony Brown
W.B.A.
Bobby Charlton
Manchester United
Martin Chivers
Tottenham Hotspur
Allan Clarke
Leeds United
Ralph Coates
Tottenham Hotspur
Charlie Cooke
Chelsea
Charlie Cooke
Chelsea
Terry Cooper
Leeds United
Ron Davies
Southampton
Wyn Davies
Newcastle United
Wyn Davies
Manchester City
Alun Evans
Liverpool
Trevor Francis
Birmingham City
Charlie George
Arsenal
 
John Giles
Leeds United
Asa Hartford
W.B.A.
Asa Hartford
Manchester City (1974)
Colin Harvey
Everton
Kevin Hector
Derby County
Steve Heighway
Liverpool
Bobby Hope
W.B.A.
Emlyn Hughes
Liverpool
Mick Jones
Leeds United
Howard Kendall
Everton
Brian Kidd
Manchester United
Francis Lee
Manchester City
Larry Lloyd
Liverpool
Peter Lorimer
Leeds United
Paul Madeley
Leeds United
Roy McFarland
Derby County
Frank McLintock
Arsenal
Bobby Moncur
Newcastle United
Bobby Moore
West Ham United
Alan Mullery
Tottenham Hotspur
Alan Mullery
Tottenham Hotspur
Peter Osgood
Chelsea
Martin Peters
Tottenham Hotspur
Bryan (Pop) Robson
West Ham United
 
Joe Royle
Everton
Peter Shilton
Leicester City
Tommy Smith
Liverpool
Pat Stanton
Hibernian
Mike Summerbee
Manchester City