1. Ronnie Clayton
Blackburn Rovers
2. Jimmy Langley
Fulham
3. Jimmy Armfield
Blackpool
4. Harry Gregg
Manchester United
5. Danny Blamchflower
Tottenham Hotspur
6. Johnny Haynes
Fulham
7. Nigel Sims
Aston Villa
8. Albert Cheesebrough
Leicester City
9. Terry Bly
Peterborough United
10. John Groves
Luton Town
11. Terry Dyson
Tottenham Hotspur
12. Ron Cope
Luton Town
13. Derek Reeves
Southampton
14. Jack Mudie
Stoke City
15. Jim Iley
Nottingham Forest
16. Tommy Harmer
Watford
17. Colin Webster
Swansea Town
18. Reg Davies
Swansea Town
19. John Elsworthy
Ipswich Town
20. John Atyeo
Bristol City
21. Freddie Goodwin
Leeds United
22. Brian Pilkington
Bolton Wanderers
23. Charlie Hurley
Sunderland
24. Dave Mackay
Tottenham Hotspur
25. Tony Kay
Sheffield Wednesday
26. Cliff Jones
Tottenham Hotspur
27. Alan Hodgkinson
Sheffield United
28. George Cohen
Fulham
29. Peter Dobing
Manchester City
30. Allan Brown
Portsmouth
31. Albert Scanlon
Newcastle United
32. Alex Parker
Everton